September 18, 2007

Saimoe update 9/18

Izumi rides the Hayate train to victory over Konomi and a barely-there Sia, while Konata triumphs over Nayuki. Surprisingly low vote total for the Konata/Nayuki match - both characters actually lost votes from round one. Nayuki also had a relatively large number of fake votes for an early round, while Konata had virtually none. Interesting, that... either the Lucky Star people didn't consider Nayuki a threat, or the emphasis on other characters and resulting reduction in Konata-time on screen is hurting her popularity. (Could be beneficial in the long run, though, if there's significant voting strength there but not voting; they can always pile in when Konata hits Isumi next round. On the other hand, if they're really not there...!)

Hayate's characters are really having an advantage of the voting schedule, with a character in each of the first five days of voting in round 2. Today, Miki from Hayate takes on Tomoe from Rozen, with Yukari from Shana in as a wild card. Three secondary characters from shows with strong voting blocks, but Tomoe was MIA in the last OAV, so it's been a long time since she's shown up. Then again, we haven't seen the school (or Miki) in quite some time in Hayate. Yukari, of course, has been gone since very early in Shana, but if you think of her as "also Shana", that could account for some of her popularity here... and the new season of Shana is just around the corner, which could light her fire just in time.

My instincts tell me to go with Konoka in B2-3. I don't trust them, though, because I haven't seen any Manabi Straight, and Hidamari Sketch does bad things to my eyes. (Abnormal character aspect ratio, owwie.) The promotional pics people are posting of Manabi just make me want to hit her, for some reason - I think I'm associating the safety helmet with old Mega Man gaming sessions. On the other hand, I've always liked Konoka as one of the few Negima characters worth the ink to put her on the page. So personal prejudices are definitely slanted that way; the fact that her round 1 performance also topped the other two, and none of them really have a meta-game reason to do well or poorly, doesn't argue against that.
Yesterday's matches:

1st place - 730 votes - Izumi / Hayate the Combat Butler
2nd place - 521 votes - Konomi / ToHeart2 OVA
3rd place - 208 votes - Sia / Shuffle! Memories

1st place - 824 votes - Konata / Lucky Star
2nd place - 674 votes - Nayuki / Kanon
3rd place - 178 votes - Ellis / El Caldazor

Today's matches:

A2-3
<<花菱美希@ハヤテのごとく!>>(Hanabishi Miki@Hayate the Combat Butler)
<<平井ゆかり@灼眼のシャナ>>(Hirai Yukari@Shakugan no Shana)
<<柏葉巴@ローゼンメイデン オーベルテューレ>>(Kashiwaba Tomoe@Rozen Maiden Ouverture)

B2-3
<<近衛木乃香@ネギま!?>>(Konoe Konoka@Negima!?)
<<稲森光香(みかん)@がくえんゆーとぴあ まなびストレート!>>(Inamori Mika(Mikan)@Gakuen Utopia Manabi Straight!)
<<沙英@ひだまりスケッチ>>(Sae@Hidamari Sketch)

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at 05:43 PM | Comments (9) | Add Comment
Post contains 478 words, total size 4 kb.

1

...and Ellis is left a small, smoking grease stain.

Why do I feel that my favorite character from Hidamari Sketch will end up the same way?

(...and why did the subbers that were working on HS disappear?  Why?  WHY?  With 3 episodes left, for heaven's sake???)

Posted by: Wonderduck at September 18, 2007 08:17 PM (+7VNs)

2 Both your questions probably have the same answers. Never got around to seeing Hidamari Sketch being that it aired around the holiday seasons and I was in Japan during that time. Is it any good?

Posted by: VitaminC at September 18, 2007 09:22 PM (ULDpd)

3

<i>Yukari, of course, has been gone since very early in Shana...</i>

I'd say so. She was killed about 3 minutes into the first episode. And it looks like she's got no better chance here.

I really did think Sia was going to do a lot better than that. A bit embarassing; I predicted she'd win.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at September 18, 2007 10:22 PM (+rSRq)

4 So, how many years before somebody gets together a "vote for the worst" bloc and elevates some inanimate-object / joke-character into the final rounds?

Posted by: Will at September 18, 2007 10:36 PM (pqGaZ)

5

It's happened. In 1998, People Magazine had an online poll for the most beautiful person, and they permitted write-ins. Someone started a viral campaign on behalf of Hank the Angry Drunken Dwarf -- who won it.

Or should have, based on the votes. The editors DQ'ed him.

In the case of this contest, I can't see there really being enough people who'd care for anything like that to happen. But you do have to wonder whether characters like Yukari and Chigusa from Shana making it this far are the result of some sort of protest vote.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at September 19, 2007 12:43 AM (+rSRq)

6 There was also a trap who got into the round before this one, wasn't there?

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at September 19, 2007 12:44 AM (+rSRq)

7 I'm not too surprised they made it in, their round 1 groups were pretty weak; Chigusa won hers with only 399 votes. I'm more impressed at how many secondary Hayate characters made it to round 2 when three of them hardly get any screen time, and Izumi even making it to round 3 where she will be crushed by Shana.

Here's to hoping next week's episode of Hayate will give Nishizawa a chance against Teana in E2-4.

Posted by: Syanaide at September 19, 2007 02:25 AM (GI5vf)

8 Not likely. Too much chance of either (a) extreme heroism, (b) tsundere finale, (c) lesbian undertone overload, or more likely (d) all of the above in next week's Strikers finale.

Hey, I like nom-nom-tan, but she's Miss Average in an over-the-top comedy - Hayate was one-hand wielding a Nambu in last week's ep against something that wouldn't have looked out of place in Gurren Lagann, after all. Teana's a tsundere with magic guns and ALSO Miss Average just because she's constantly surrounded by the equivalent of minor demigods...

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at September 19, 2007 05:48 PM (LMDdY)

9

VitaminC, I liked Hidamari Sketch quite a bit.  "Slice-of-Life" doesn't even begin to describe it.  Put it this way: people like to say that Azumanga Daioh has no plot (I disagree, but that's neither here nor there). 

In comparison to Hidamari Sketch, Azumanga has more plot than a cemetary.

Posted by: Wonderduck at September 19, 2007 08:56 PM (+7VNs)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
16kb generated in CPU 0.132, elapsed 0.1386 seconds.
30 queries taking 0.1249 seconds, 58 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.