August 23, 2007

Saimoe update 8/23

More heavy voting, though not on the same level as yesterday's tremendous pile of votes. Hinagiku cruises to a crushing victory over Jun the trap, showing that as much as people like to throw monkey wrenches in the works, they don't like it as much as they like student council presidents with agoraphobia and a touch of tsundere.

The other two rounds came out quite interestingly, though. Apparently Aono from Sola was in the lead until quite late, Japan-time, so either a tremendous amount of Strikers voters were up late, or got organized at the last minute. (Not having seen Sola, I can't say whether she's moe or not. But more moe than Ana? Criminy!) Caro, whose competition wasn't as stiff as Vita's, ended up with more votes and a big margin of victory.

C-4 today is... okay, I'd say "explosive!", but it would be a terrible pun, and it's more of an interesting showdown than a red-hot one. Steven mentioned his opinion that Nobue isn't moe at all, but now that I've read some of the manga, I have to disagree a little; she's mean, she's a smoker and a drinker at 16, and I actually like her more than her sister, who's just a target but not as cute of one as Matsuri. But Chika took more votes in the early voting (where, interestingly enough, Nobue and Tokiko both got 416.) Tokiko has an outside chance, but being in the same round as Nobue will hurt her, I think - she'd do better as a contrast between a couple of worthless moeblobs than against another character with a bit of bite to her. I'll call it for Chika just because of that split...

C-8 is tough. I couldn't get past the double-wide presentation of Hidamari Sketch, so I can't say whether she's actually moe or not. But I'd like to see her win, simply because the other two results would end up meaningless. Shari winning would end up against Caro in the next round, where she'd be slaughtered completely. Makoto (big) would end up against the regular Makoto, and while a Kanon duel has some appeal, it's not like Makoto (big) has any real chance.

In fact, each respective show is actually better off if their character DOESN'T win this round. Round 2 is already Caro vs. Makoto vs. the winner of C-8. That's going to be a close one no matter how you slice it. But splitting a show's vote between two candidates is just going to Nader the other one to victory. Less of a threat from Shari - only the most hardcore glasses fetishist could vote for her over Caro - but it'll still be a real test of organization to see how this turns out.

C-12 is the undercard of the day, though I realize there's quite a few Feena fans out there. Not really familiar with any of the shows, though all three characters qualified from the first preliminary, and Matsuri came in second in hers. After yesterday, we know the Sola fans are out there, so perhaps they'll turn out in order to get another shot at Vita next round?
Yesterday's results:

1位 1103 votes Katsura Hinagiku@Hayate the Combat Butler

2位 443
votes Watarase Jun@Happiness!
3位 321
votes Byakudan Kagome@Strawberry Panic

1位 884
votes Caro Ru Lushe@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS
2位 531
votes Primula(Rimu)@SHUFFLE! MEMORIES
3位 297
votes Uma@Renkin Sankyuu Magical? Poka~n

1位 783
votes Vita@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS
2位 600
votes Morimiya Aono@sola
3位 511
votes Ana Coppola@Ichigo Mashimaro

Today's matches:

C-04
<<伊藤千佳@苺ましまろ>>(Itou Chika@Ichigo Mashimaro)
<<伊藤伸恵@苺ましまろ>>(Itou Nobue@Ichigo Mashimaro)
<<津村斗貴子@武装錬金>>(Tsumura Tokiko@Busourenkin)

C-08
<<宮子@ひだまりスケッチ>>(Miyako@Hidamari Sketch)
<<沢渡真琴(本物/沢渡さんとこの真琴お姉さん)@Kanon>>(Sawatari Makoto(The Genuine/Sawatari-san's Makoto-onee-san)@Kanon)
<<シャリオ・フィニーノ(シャーリー)@魔法少女リリカルなのはStrikerS>>(Shar io Finieno(Shari)@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)

C-12
<<四方茉莉@sola>>(Shihou Matsuri@sola)
<<赤ずきん@おとぎ銃士 赤ずきん>>(Akazukin@Otogi Jushi Akazukin)
<<フィーナ・ファム・アーシュライト@夜明け前より瑠璃色な Crescent Love>>(Feena Fam Earthlight@Yoake Mae Yori Ruriiro na Crescent Love)

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at 12:33 PM | Comments (2) | Add Comment
Post contains 627 words, total size 7 kb.

1

In the anime (which is what this contest is about), Nobue has her 21st birthday in the first episode. Instead of being in high school, she's in college. I guess they were worried about the smoking and drinking. But I think it also makes the big-sister/little-sister jokes more funny when the age difference is 9 years instead of 4 years.

Chika isn't moe, because she's a cipher. She has less personality than anyone else in the show except maybe John, the ferret. There's more to moe than looks; it takes personality, and Chika doesn't have any. (She's the series straight man.)

I'm appalled by how badly Anna Coppola did. I don't know that I expected her to win, but I thought she'd do better than she did. It looks like the Nanoha voting bloc is really strong.

As expected, Uma got creamed. Alas, poor Magipoka. I bet none of the cast members from that series make it past this round. (Maybe Pachira will; there's the goth-loli aspect that may help her.)

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at August 23, 2007 05:18 PM (+rSRq)

2 I, too, am appalled. Don't get me wrong - I like Vita as a character. It's not that she isn't moe. It is true she's not as moe as she used to be, but oy! Coming in third... no love for Ana.

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at August 23, 2007 07:50 PM (LMDdY)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
16kb generated in CPU 0.1355, elapsed 0.7362 seconds.
30 queries taking 0.7233 seconds, 51 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.