August 21, 2007
Saimoe update 8/21
And yesterday's rounds come out as expected, though voting was in general pretty light. Vivio did manage to pull more than half the vote in her round, but still comes in with 730 votes. The real surprise for me was Makoto's performance - sure, with light voting and real competition, I expect the vote to be split up, but her total was low enough that it calls into question the strength of the Kanon voting block. Suzu did a little better, but against a lot less opposition.
I'll start with C-10 today, as it's definitely the under-card of the day. Misa pulled a few more votes in the prelims, but only by a bit, and it's tough to say which way the votes are going to break, especially because today's voting is going to be focused on the other rounds - that is, nobody's going to bother voting for just this round's sake. I have to give Clare a disadvantage here, just because she's got the wrong assets for the tournament - while she'd be likely to win a battle royale in her round, she's just not in the possession of a lot of moe.
C-6... hoo boy. On paper this is an utter no-brainer. Yutaka had to come in through the second prelim round, and Nanoha won her round in the first prelim (not even mentioning the, y'know, former champion thing.) But Yutaka's actually a stronger contender than she looks. When her voting came up in the first prelim, she hadn't appeared yet, and was running off pure Lucky Star votes. Since then, she's established herself in the Izumi household, displayed bunches of cute-little-girl moe, and been generally precious in an "aww" fashion.
Nanoha, on the other hand, isn't a little loli anymore (though, of course, plenty of people remember the young Nanoha...) Being nice and curvy is not an advantage in this tournament, generally speaking. That said, the new season has a Nanoha that's subtly more like the fan vision of the character - some indiscriminate "White Devil" violence, some implied lesbianism (no, they don't actually come out and say it, but she's living in an apartment with Fate... with one bed... so even though it's presented completely innocently, the logical leap is not difficult.)
Nanoha still has the advantage, I think - when it comes down to it, Yutaka's relative lack of appearances would prove telling. However, if a lot of supporters from other series came in and piled up on the vote, it's theoretically possible that an already-strong Yutaka could come out on top. (This would prove to be self-destructive in the long run - galvanizing Nanoha fans with that many characters left on the bracket is not a good idea - but there you go.)
C-2 would have come out completely differently if it had been B-2 or D-2 instead. Luna -is- a cute, evil little idol singer. Sure, she's relegated to the "unsuccessful romantic rival" role, but she's definitely the type of character to do well in Saimoe. (Minus points for excessive crotch-kicking, though! Jackhammer action is not cool.) In contrast, Subaru is definitely a tomboy, with her moe coming mostly from overconsumption of ice cream (it's not a cone so much as a cluster when she's done loading it up, but when you eat a scoop at a time...) and her pursuit of her partner/roommate (nothin' implied about THIS lesbianism - though non-consensual groping is also not cool, it's not cool in a way that attracts votes).
Healthy and curvy versus little loli usually comes out bad for healthy and curvy here. But with Nanoha drawing in voters in the match next door, Subaru's chances are much greater than they'd ordinarily be - she can expect a lot of votes to carry over, and it just might be enough to do the job.
Yesterday's results:
1ä½ã€€669 votes Suzu@Nagasarete Airantou
2ä½ã€€418 votes Kusugawa Sasara@OVA ToHeart2
3ä½ã€€280 votes Aaeru@Simoun
1ä½ã€€731 votes Vivio@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS
2ä½ã€€360 votes Yamada Asu@Binbou Shimai Monogatari
3ä½ã€€346 votes Cecile Croomy@Code Geass Lelouche of the Rebellion
1ä½ã€€625 votes Sawatari Makoto@Kanon
2ä½ã€€523 votes Hinaichigo@Rozen Maiden Ouverture
3ä½ã€€404 votes Yoshida Kazumi@Shakugan no Shana Series
Today's matches:
C-02
<<江戸å‰ç•™å¥ˆï¼ 瀬戸ã®èбå«>>(Edomae Runa@Seto no Hanayome)
<<スãƒãƒ«ãƒ»ãƒŠã‚«ã‚¸ãƒžï¼ 锿³•少女リリカルãªã®ã¯StrikerS>>(Subaru Nakajima@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)
<<æ¾å¹³çž³åï¼ ãƒžãƒªã‚¢æ§˜ãŒã¿ã¦ã‚‹ OVA>>(Matsudaira Touko@Maria-sama ga Miteru OVA)
C-06
<<高町ãªã®ã¯ï¼ 锿³•少女リリカルãªã®ã¯StrikerS>>(Takamachi Nanoha@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)
<<å°æ—©å·ã‚†ãŸã‹ï¼ らã☆ã™ãŸ>>(Kobayakawa Yutaka@Lucky Star)
<<神河ç¹åï¼ sola>>(Kamikawa Mayuko@sola)
C-10
<<å¼¥æµ·ç ‚ï¼ DEATH NOTE>>(Amane Misa@DEATH NOTE)
<<ã‚¢ã‚¤ï¼ ARIA The NATURAL>>(Ai@ARIA The NATURAL)
<<ã‚¯ãƒ¬ã‚¢ï¼ CLAYMORE>>(Clare@CLAYMORE)
Comments are disabled.
Post is locked.
I'll start with C-10 today, as it's definitely the under-card of the day. Misa pulled a few more votes in the prelims, but only by a bit, and it's tough to say which way the votes are going to break, especially because today's voting is going to be focused on the other rounds - that is, nobody's going to bother voting for just this round's sake. I have to give Clare a disadvantage here, just because she's got the wrong assets for the tournament - while she'd be likely to win a battle royale in her round, she's just not in the possession of a lot of moe.
C-6... hoo boy. On paper this is an utter no-brainer. Yutaka had to come in through the second prelim round, and Nanoha won her round in the first prelim (not even mentioning the, y'know, former champion thing.) But Yutaka's actually a stronger contender than she looks. When her voting came up in the first prelim, she hadn't appeared yet, and was running off pure Lucky Star votes. Since then, she's established herself in the Izumi household, displayed bunches of cute-little-girl moe, and been generally precious in an "aww" fashion.
Nanoha, on the other hand, isn't a little loli anymore (though, of course, plenty of people remember the young Nanoha...) Being nice and curvy is not an advantage in this tournament, generally speaking. That said, the new season has a Nanoha that's subtly more like the fan vision of the character - some indiscriminate "White Devil" violence, some implied lesbianism (no, they don't actually come out and say it, but she's living in an apartment with Fate... with one bed... so even though it's presented completely innocently, the logical leap is not difficult.)
Nanoha still has the advantage, I think - when it comes down to it, Yutaka's relative lack of appearances would prove telling. However, if a lot of supporters from other series came in and piled up on the vote, it's theoretically possible that an already-strong Yutaka could come out on top. (This would prove to be self-destructive in the long run - galvanizing Nanoha fans with that many characters left on the bracket is not a good idea - but there you go.)
C-2 would have come out completely differently if it had been B-2 or D-2 instead. Luna -is- a cute, evil little idol singer. Sure, she's relegated to the "unsuccessful romantic rival" role, but she's definitely the type of character to do well in Saimoe. (Minus points for excessive crotch-kicking, though! Jackhammer action is not cool.) In contrast, Subaru is definitely a tomboy, with her moe coming mostly from overconsumption of ice cream (it's not a cone so much as a cluster when she's done loading it up, but when you eat a scoop at a time...) and her pursuit of her partner/roommate (nothin' implied about THIS lesbianism - though non-consensual groping is also not cool, it's not cool in a way that attracts votes).
Healthy and curvy versus little loli usually comes out bad for healthy and curvy here. But with Nanoha drawing in voters in the match next door, Subaru's chances are much greater than they'd ordinarily be - she can expect a lot of votes to carry over, and it just might be enough to do the job.
Yesterday's results:
1ä½ã€€669 votes Suzu@Nagasarete Airantou
2ä½ã€€418 votes Kusugawa Sasara@OVA ToHeart2
3ä½ã€€280 votes Aaeru@Simoun
1ä½ã€€731 votes Vivio@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS
2ä½ã€€360 votes Yamada Asu@Binbou Shimai Monogatari
3ä½ã€€346 votes Cecile Croomy@Code Geass Lelouche of the Rebellion
1ä½ã€€625 votes Sawatari Makoto@Kanon
2ä½ã€€523 votes Hinaichigo@Rozen Maiden Ouverture
3ä½ã€€404 votes Yoshida Kazumi@Shakugan no Shana Series
Today's matches:
C-02
<<江戸å‰ç•™å¥ˆï¼ 瀬戸ã®èбå«>>(Edomae Runa@Seto no Hanayome)
<<スãƒãƒ«ãƒ»ãƒŠã‚«ã‚¸ãƒžï¼ 锿³•少女リリカルãªã®ã¯StrikerS>>(Subaru Nakajima@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)
<<æ¾å¹³çž³åï¼ ãƒžãƒªã‚¢æ§˜ãŒã¿ã¦ã‚‹ OVA>>(Matsudaira Touko@Maria-sama ga Miteru OVA)
C-06
<<高町ãªã®ã¯ï¼ 锿³•少女リリカルãªã®ã¯StrikerS>>(Takamachi Nanoha@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)
<<å°æ—©å·ã‚†ãŸã‹ï¼ らã☆ã™ãŸ>>(Kobayakawa Yutaka@Lucky Star)
<<神河ç¹åï¼ sola>>(Kamikawa Mayuko@sola)
C-10
<<å¼¥æµ·ç ‚ï¼ DEATH NOTE>>(Amane Misa@DEATH NOTE)
<<ã‚¢ã‚¤ï¼ ARIA The NATURAL>>(Ai@ARIA The NATURAL)
<<ã‚¯ãƒ¬ã‚¢ï¼ CLAYMORE>>(Clare@CLAYMORE)
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at
10:40 AM
| Comments (3)
| Add Comment
Post contains 737 words, total size 7 kb.
1
I sure called C-09 wrong. Yikes! Frankly, I'm just as happy. Even though the voice is Kawasumi Ayako, I didn't like the Kazumi character.
Posted by: Steven Den Beste at August 21, 2007 02:16 PM (+rSRq)
2
I don't think the Kanon fanbloc is weak, I think it's just that everybody got real sick of Makoto. Her arc is almost twice as long as all the other girls, and half of it was her in dumb animal mode.
Posted by: Wonderduck at August 21, 2007 07:43 PM (ywZa8)
3
What, you were serious?! I thought that was exquisite sarcasm! (Seriously, busty characters are at a serious disadvantage in this tourney.)
There was an awful lot of Makoto, and she's definitely not my favorite Kanon girl, but still.
There was an awful lot of Makoto, and she's definitely not my favorite Kanon girl, but still.
Posted by: Avatar_exADV at August 21, 2007 07:55 PM (LMDdY)
16kb generated in CPU 0.0185, elapsed 0.0716 seconds.
30 queries taking 0.0598 seconds, 52 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
30 queries taking 0.0598 seconds, 52 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.








