July 27, 2007

Saimoe second prelim 7/27

Because it's not a day on the Ego's Nest without a Saimoe post. ;p

Rules change a bit for the second prelim. These are the characters that came in 9th through 32nd in the first prelim. You can vote for up to six, and the top sixteen of the forty-eight (forty-nine, for a couple rounds... there were some ties) will advance to the main tourney. Nine total days of voting, to give us another 144 characters to add to the 144 that made it in already.

Picking winners among these will be tough, simply because the relative performance band has narrowed so much (and because it's difficult to predict where secondary votes will go - people show up to vote for one or two characters they really like, then toss in a few more that they like a little just to fill up the ballot.) Looking at relative performance from the first round, we can expect Pachira from Magical Pokan, Akira from Aria, and Barasuishou from Rozen to do well - they all came in 9th or 10th in their first prelim round.

After that, it's a toss-up between Balalaika from Black Lagoon (not moe at all, but somewhat awesome), Carim from StrikerS (slight nun moe, but do we really need more of these?), Ama from Shuffle, Megu from Rozen (sickly moe, emo moe, Suigintou halo moe), the Red Loli from Saint October, and Nadie from El Caldazor de la Bruja. I personally like Saki from Genshiken, but she ain't gonna make it.

Today's round:

<<知恵留美子@ひぐらしのなく頃に>>(Chie Rumiko@Higurashi no Naku Koro ni)
<<龍宮真名@ネギま!?>>(Tatsumiya Mana@Negima!?)
<<神楽まりえ@となグラ!>>(Kagura Marie@Tona Gura!)
<<たるろって@京四郎と永遠の空>>(Tarlotte@Kyoushirou to Towa no Sora)
<<上条沙耶@はぴねす!>>(Kamijou Saya@Happiness!)
<<吉田歩美@名探偵コナン>>(Yoshida Ayumi@Meitantei Conan)
<<エスメラルダ@Saint October>>(Esmerelda@Saint October)
<<ハーマイオニ@ロミオ×ジュリエット>>(Hermione@Romeo x Juliet)
<<穂積さやか@夜明け前より瑠璃色な Crescent Love>>(Hozumi Sayaka@Yoake Mae Yori Ruriiro na Crescent Love)
<<夢原のぞみ(キュアドリーム)@Yes!プリキュア5>>(Yumehara Nozomi(Cure Dream)@Yes! PreCure5)
<<パキラ@錬金3級まじかる?ぽか〜ん>>(Pachira@Renkin Sankyuu Magical? Poka~n)
<<藤枝七恵@スカイガールズ>>(Fujieda Nanae@Sky Girls)
<<朝霧麻亜子(まーりゃん先輩)@OVA ToHeart2>>(Asagiri Maako(Maaryan-senpai)@OVA ToHeart2)
<<ビビン@ふしぎ星の☆ふたご姫Gyu!>>(Pipin@Fushigi Boshi no Futago Hime Gyu!)
<<黒井ななこ@らき☆すた>>(Kukroi Nanako@Lucky Star)
<<鬼丸美輝@無敵看板娘>>(Onimaru Miki@Muteki Kanban Musume)
<<真田さん@円盤皇女ワるきゅーレ 時と夢と銀河の宴>>(Sanada-san@UFO Princess valkyrie Toki to Ginga no Utage)
<<橋本文恵(フミエ)@電脳コイル>>(Hashimoto Fumie@Dennou Coil)
<<バラライカ@BLACK LAGOON The Second Barrage>>(Balalaika@BLACK LAGOON The Second Barrage)
<<山田あす@貧乏姉妹物語>>(Yamada Asu@Binbou Shimai Monogatari)
<<リリオ@エル・カザド>>(Lirio@EL CAZADOR DE LA BRUJA)
<<朽木ルキア@BLEACH>>(Kuchiki Rukia@BLEACH)
<<アリス・L・マルヴィン@パンプキン・シザーズ>>(Alice L. Malvin@Pumpkin Scissors)
<<カリム・グラシア@魔法少女リリカルなのはStrikerS>>(Carim Gracia@Mahou Syoujo Lyrical Nanoha StrikerS)
<<サラ・アディエマス@スクールランブル 二学期>>(Sarah Adiemas@School Rumble Second Term)
<<時雨亜麻@SHUFFLE! MEMORIES>>(Shigure Ama@SHUFFLE! MEMORIES)
<<茅原みのり@らき☆すた>>(Chihara Minori@Lucky Star)
<<朝倉和美@ネギま!?>>(Asakura Kazumi@Negima!?)
<<篠岡千代@おおきく振りかぶって>>(Shinooka Chiyo@Ookiku Furikabutte)
<<峰岸あやの@らき☆すた>>(Minagishi Ayano@Lucky Star)
<<薔薇水晶@ローゼンメイデン オーベルテューレ>>(Barasuisyou@Rozen Maiden Ouverture)
<<ミルフィーユ・桜葉@ギャラクシーエンジェる〜ん>>(Milfeulle Sakuraba@Galaxy Angel-Rune)
<<柿崎めぐ@ローゼンメイデン オーベルテューレ>>(Kakizaki Megu@Rozen Maiden Ouverture)
<<なでしこ@いぬかみっ!>>(Nadeshiko@Inukami!)
<<春日部咲@げんしけん>>(Kasukabe Saki@Genshiken)
<<リースリット・ノエル@夜明け前より瑠璃色な Crescent Love>>(Wreathlit Noel@Yoake Mae Yori Ruriiro na Crescent Love)
<<四葉五月@ネギま!?>>(Yotsuba Satsuki@Negima!?)
<<花園静馬@ストロベリー・パニック>>(Hanazono Shizuma@Strawberry Panic)
<<聖三咲(赤ロリ)@Saint October>>(Hijiri Misaki(Red Loli)@Saint October)
<<晃・E・フェラーリ@ARIA The NATURAL>>(Akira E. Ferrari@ARIA The NATURAL)
<<夜神粧裕@DEATH NOTE>>(Yagami Sayu@DEATH NOTE)
<<まぁ(まぁ社長)@ARIA The NATURAL>>(Maa(Maa-Shachou)@ARIA The NATURAL)
<<ワるきゅーレ@円盤皇女ワるきゅーレ 時と夢と銀河の宴>>(Valkyrie@UFO Princess valkyrie Toki to Ginga no Utage)
<<鈴風小夜(トゥルーデ/シルフィーヌ)@おとぎ銃士 赤ずきん>>(Suzukaze Sayo(Trude/Sylphiene)@Otogi Jushi Akazukin)
<<笹森花梨@OVA ToHeart2>>(Sasamori Karin@OVA ToHeart2)
<<マオ@シャイニング・ティアーズ×ウィンド>>(Mao@Shining Tears x Wind)
<<シャーウッド姫@怪物王女>>(Sherwood@Kaibutsu Oujo)
<<ナディ@エル・カザド>>(Nadie@EL CAZADOR DE LA BRUJA)
<<水無月かれん(キュアアクア)@Yes!プリキュア5>>(Minazuki Karen(Cure Aqua)@Yes! PreCure5)

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at 06:44 PM | Comments (8) | Add Comment
Post contains 471 words, total size 9 kb.

1

Yagami Sayu@DEATH NOTE

If this is Light's sister, can I vote for the movie version, please?

Posted by: Wonderduck at July 27, 2007 07:46 PM (6krEN)

2 Sure, nobody's going to interrogate you on the topic or anything. ;p

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at July 28, 2007 03:44 AM (LMDdY)

3 what do you think of the idea of shorten the prelim. drop the 2nd prelim and shorten the first to 12 rounds and advance the top 24 of each round. That would still give 288 characters total but save about 17 days.

Posted by: Xellos-_^ at July 28, 2007 11:09 AM (12gxe)

4 Dunno, though. That means you're advancing the top 24 out of over 200 per round; I have trouble mentally parsing the lists of 150, so increasing that number would really mess with me.

I do like the second prelims, though, because it gives people a chance to organize behind a character; it doesn't take all that many votes to get out of a second prelim round, so an aggressive campaigning effort would definitely put most characters into the win column. But it's a little more focused, so people aren't asking "hey, why am I considering voting for this obscure character when moebombs 1-10 are in the round?"

That doesn't mean that character will go on to eventual victory, but it might give enough of a base to get a character into the second round...

There's plenty of ways you could save time with Saimoe, but I figure that it's against the point - shortening the process is something the organizers are specifically not worried about, or they would have just set up a smaller bracket to begin with.

Posted by: Avatar_exADV at July 28, 2007 11:57 AM (LMDdY)

5

Xellos, I think you're missing the point. The purpose of this is to drive traffic to the site which is doing it.

Shortening the process is a negative, not a positive.

Posted by: Steven Den Beste at July 28, 2007 01:24 PM (+rSRq)

6 Xellos hit the nail on the head.  Holding the tournament over the course of several months, and using that time to promote activity on the site is one of the main stated reasons of the tournament.

Another reason is to give people an opportunity to promote characters they love.  Having the long prelims and more focus on secondary characters causes people to go, "Man, I've never heard of character X but she's really popular" or, "I watched one episode of this show and didn't really get into it, but a lot of people seem to really like it.  Maybe I should check it out."

I watched Rozen Maiden largely as a result of all the attention it got in SaiMoe2005, and last year decided to check out MagiPoka and Utawarerumono as a result of SaiMoe exposure.  All three of those are shows I enjoyed a great deal, especially MagiPoka, and I probably would'nt have given them a second thought if I wasn't following the tournament.

Posted by: 0rion at July 28, 2007 02:38 PM (9e2pT)

7 Doh...meant to say Steven hit the nail on the head.  OTL

Posted by: 0rion at July 28, 2007 02:40 PM (9e2pT)

8 While her quest for bigger breasts is certain indear her to Japanese males (well, all males in fact), I also think Pachira is getting a major boost from sharing a seiyuu with Suzumiya Haruhi.

Posted by: Will at July 28, 2007 11:18 PM (olS40)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

Comments are disabled. Post is locked.
21kb generated in CPU 0.0495, elapsed 0.0609 seconds.
30 queries taking 0.0516 seconds, 57 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.